Jaster's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Hartrup and Oatly - Secret Friend]

This is pretty funny and looks great but I think your first episode had a little more charm, this is really weird for a second episode even tho it is really funny. I kinda wish this was an episode you made later on cuz it was really similar to episode 1 in that it's Hartrup trying to get away with something he's not supposed to be doing, I personally would've prefered if you did an episode that focuses more on Oatley or even the boss. But yeah, as it's own thing I still like it and look foward to seeing more.

Bassetfilms responds:

agreed. I also think this one is too similar to the first, when I get around to making the next ep it will be pretty different. :^]

[Frank and Bill]

This isn't bad, It's nice to see you finally make something. But I'll admit I don't LOVE it, I can appreciate it for being simple but at the same time had I not known this took 2 years to make I think I'd enjoy it more. That's not really anything wrong with the cartoon itself but rather that time that was taken to make it could've been used on something more worth while. It wasn't laugh out loud funny for the most part but is has some charm with it's presentation, I'll say this at least, the 3rd impact to Bill got me so not bad there. I do like the cartoon but I think you could've done better.

AnimationCrave responds:

I totally see your point of view, definitely took way longer than it should’ve. And not really a belly laugh cartoon, more like a quick chuckle. I do appreciate the thoughts and appreciate you watching and taking the time to leave your honest thoughts on it!!

[COME ON! (loop)]

Put this on the art portal

claykidNG responds:

uhm...don’t think u can do that! ^0^

[Angie In School]

I love this! It's really nice to see you finally make something, I'm looking foward to seeing more content. I would like to see more of this character, Maybe a longer story? Would be nice, but it's still a good start!

[Are We Friends?]

Loved

[MindFuzz 3: Never Say Die]

This is the best one you guys have done yet! I can tell a lot of effort was put in from everyone involved, I really liked how this how was less random and had sort of a motif, while maintaining the same feeling a variety show. A lot of fun overall. Good job guys

[Friday Night Funkin' Mockup Intro]

Not bad for the amount of time put into it

[Casting Call]

Nice work from everyone invovled, don't get me wrong. Edd's new voice is perfect and it was nice seeing Oney come back but this short just feels pointless. You guys could've just done a short that'd stand on it's own with the new voices and people would get it. The direction Eddsworld seems to be going in seems really self indulgent and indirectly disrespectful, I know it's well meaning and it's all in good fun but there's something off about everyone inserting themselves in the cartoon. It feels like Edds world has truly lost Edd, it's more corporate now, esentially anyones world at this point.

[Roommates - A Series of Manifested Events]

Glad to see everyone's finished work! This was a lot of fun to be apart of.

[Orla's Ear Worm]

This is a silent cartoon done right! Has amazing shots and fun animation with such a great freaky vibe, the sound choices are also excellent! They really set the mood and feel appropriate. Really great stuff, I look forward to seeing more of your work in the future.